All insights
Gold

Allocated and unallocated gold: what you actually own

Allocated vs. Unallocated Metals

Conceptual editorial artwork for Allocated and unallocated gold: what you actually own

Allocated and unallocated gold are not the same claim

Unallocated holders are unsecured creditors, while allocated metal sits outside the custodian's assets.

Two forms of gold ownership sit behind most of the wholesale market, and they are not interchangeable. The London Bullion Market Association, the trade body for the London market, sets out both in its guide to the London precious metals markets. The first is the unallocated account, where a balance is recorded in ounces, no specific bars are assigned, and the holder has no entitlement to particular metal. The guide is direct about where that leaves the holder: "the client in this scenario is an unsecured creditor."

That structure is not incidental. Unallocated balances let the London market settle trades without physically moving 400 troy ounce bars between vaults, and the guide describes them as the most popular way of trading, settling and holding gold. Nearly all over the counter gold and silver trading clears through that system, so the arrangement exists to deliver liquidity rather than possession.

An allocated account works differently. Specific bars are assigned to a named customer and segregated from other metal in the vault, with the customer holding title and the dealer holding the metal as custodian. By the association's description, that metal does not form part of the dealer's assets, and an allocated account cannot be overdrawn, because nothing is available to lend against.

The Bank of England runs its gold business on an allocated basis and documents the consequence plainly. Customers retain title to specific bars in its vaults, and gold held for customers does not appear on the Bank's balance sheet, because those customers hold named bars rather than a claim on the Bank for a weight of metal. The Bank's own holdings amount to two bars, both in its museum.

Bank capital rules draw the same line. Allocated physical gold has long carried a zero risk weight, since it introduces no credit risk and sits outside the custodian's balance sheet, and Basel III did not change that. What the Net Stable Funding Ratio did was attach a funding requirement to gold held on a bank's own balance sheet, at a factor of 85 percent, which raised the cost of running unallocated positions relative to allocated custody. Gold is not classified among high quality liquid assets, having been excluded when those rules were drafted for want of trading data, and the World Gold Council has published its view that the classification should be reconsidered.

The distinction has become more consequential as metal is tokenized. A token records a claim, and it carries whatever claim sits beneath it. A token representing an unallocated balance leaves holders as unsecured creditors of the counterparty holding the metal, while a token representing allocated metal gives holders title to identified bars held outside the custodian's estate. Both are buildable, and the difference does not appear on a price chart or in a blockchain record.

What to watch is disclosure: whether a product states which of the two arrangements it uses, whether bars are identified by serial number, weight and refiner, whether an auditor counts bars or relies on a custodian's confirmation, and how holders rank if the custodian fails. Those details are documented for some products and not for others.

Sources: London Bullion Market Association, A Guide to the London Precious Metals Markets (https://www.lbma.org.uk/publications/the-otc-guide); Bank of England, Gold (https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/gold); World Gold Council, Basel III and the gold market (https://www.gold.org/goldhub/gold-focus/2021/06/basel-iii-and-gold-market).

This article is general information, not investment advice. Facts from other publications are their reporting, linked above.

More insights